Tag: real estate

Market Commentary 3/3/2023

Posted on by Damon Germanides

Strong Jobs Data and Inflation Increase Burden On Fed

After a grueling week of higher interest rates, some of Thursday’s Fed speak soothed the markets. As we have previously mentioned, we are not huge fans of the ceaseless opining that has become the norm from the Fed. We are often confused by Fed comments which tend to require clarification later on. 

We would prefer to focus on the data. Employment remains tight, as evidenced by weekly unemployment statistics and a very strong January Jobs Report. Although we are seeing many large corporate layoffs along with signs of a slowing economy, the unemployment data suggests the economy is much more resilient than many experts assumed. Inflation is also proving to be stickier. While some inflation will certainly be transitory, wage inflation and service inflation are less likely to fall. As the 10-year Treasury surged above 4.000% this week, bond traders are more accepting of the idea that persistent inflation could drive interest rates higher and make qualifying for a mortgage more difficult.

Higher interest and widening spreads are starting to negatively affect the commercial real estate markets, especially office spaces.  Lenders are becoming more selective in their loan decision-making process. We expect to see more and more defaults within the commercial space as the era of easy money comes to an end.  In the single-family home sector, activity on the eve of the busy spring buying season is showing signs of life. Nonetheless, volume is a far cry from the frantic pace of recent years.  Qualifying for a home remains challenging but we are seeing buyers change their expectations based on affordability. We assume that price adjustments will be required to close the gap between buyer and seller.

The deeply inverted yield curve is troubling to us and should be taken as a serious precursor to a recession. No one knows what type of black swan event is circling until it happens, but a sharp drop in interest rates amidst the realization the economy has stalled is one possible outcome in the coming months. Also, a slow grinding economy with fits and starts remains another possibility in what is being called a soft-landing outcome. The present moment can only be described as unusual. The economy seems to be slowing, but inflation remains high. Housing activity is at a multi-decade low, but wages continue to go up as employment remains tight. Only in time, will we know the true impacts of Fed policy.            

Market Commentary 2.24.2023

Posted on by Damon Germanides

Markets Rethink Inflation Amidst Fed Pivot

The quote “this too shall pass” may be apropos for the strain of higher inflation, higher interest rates, and increased volatility is having on all of us. For the mortgage market, it is an arm-wrestling match with interest rates, each day, in real-time. 

Unfortunately, our instinct has been that once inflation is left to run hot for longer, it infects all aspects of the economy and does not retreat quickly.  We opined recently that we were concerned Fed Chairman Powell’s press conference in early February was way too optimistic about the pace of cooling inflation. Also odd was the Fed’s belief that financial conditions were nearing a neutral level of tightening while most economists were seeing financial conditions ease up again.  All of this has now come home to roost with CPI, PPI, January jobs report, and PCE, all of which came in hotter than expected. It is now widely believed that the Fed will need to raise interest rates further while also holding rates higher for longer to ensure inflation is wrung out of the system.

Financial Reality: Recession, Rates, & The Grind

Regardless of the popular belief that rates will continue to rise for a longer period, we suspect that the economy may be in a recession. As a result, the higher cost of living is impacting spending, which may come through in the data sooner than later. Mortgage rates are certainly making it harder for borrowers to qualify for home loans as well as purchase or refinance commercial properties. Bank liquidity remains tight, credit card balances are soaring, and high-risk auto loans are rolling over. All are signs that the consumer is under pressure. The lagging effects of monetary policy take time and the thinking is that the jumbo rate hikes from last year take about 9 months to work their way into the system. Should the economy fall into an official recession, the Fed will be forced to lower rates. At what point the Fed rate hikes break something is unknown, but we are no longer in a low-interest rate market as interest has returned to a normal level. 

Our motto is that you must live in the world you are in, and not the one you want. Applying this to real estate means working much harder for much less, and seeing deals come and go. Again, we are of the firm belief that many prospective buyers are actively looking for a discount on the price to overcome the big increase in monthly mortgage payments. We are starting to see signs of more favorable negotiations between buyers and sellers, which is encouraging. For the deals that big banks refuse to fund, local banks are doing whatever they can to make common sense decisions on successfully closing such deals. The reinstatement of a busy market will take time. For now, it remains a grind. 

Market Commentary 1/20/23

Posted on by Damon Germanides

Job Loss & Poor Housing Data Drive Mortgage Rates Lower

It is becoming increasingly difficult to argue that the economy is not slowing. Several major public companies, including Microsoft and Google, have announced layoffs. Now, most economists ally with the recession camp. Retail sales were very poor, existing housing sales are at a 13-year-low, the yield curve is extremely inverted, and long bonds are falling. Nonetheless, the Fed is resolute in raising short-term interest rates to eliminate inflation. Why, with so much negative sentiment, is the Fed dead set on doing this?  The answer lies in what the Fed is seeing in the job market and persistent wage growth. A survey of regional Fed data supports the notion that although wages are moderating, many parts of the job market remain tight and wage pressure has yet to soften. As wages constitute a large chunk of any company’s expenses, higher wages lead to higher prices, assuming the business can pass along those prices. 

Looking at the history of the economy, the Fed has at times, been truly unsuccessful in pushing down inflation. For example, the grim inflation episodes of the late 1970s and early 1980s led to several rate increases and declines. As a result, the Fed had to resort to very high short-term interest rates to finally quell inflation. We suspect that the Fed Chairman does not want to be remembered for failing to get the job done on inflation. He would rather see equity and real estate prices come down than risk a re-acceleration of inflation.

Even with the Fed’s rate hikes, and jaw-boning the markets constantly, financial conditions have eased since late last year. The 10-year Treasury is south of 3.500%, mortgage rates have dipped, and global equities have rallied. This is not what the Fed wants. Therefore, the Fed will be raising short-term rates yet again in early February. Odds are for a .25 bp increase, but don’t count out another .50 bp as their terminal rate target is above 5.00% (Fed Funds are currently at 4.25% -4.50%)

Distress in commercial real estate is starting to make it closer to the front page. There are about $175 billion in troubled loans globally, many of which are coming due later in 2023 and 2024 with the focus being on the office. Some residential areas like Austin and Boise experienced massive price appreciation during the pandemic and are now seeing prices come down. However, strong coastal market prices are holding steady. This is due to the combination of both a robust and diversified economy with low levels of inventory serving as a floor to steep declines. Mortgage rates have drifted lower. Lenders are now thinking about 2023 production goals on how to make loan requests work, especially on the portfolio bank side of the business. This is a welcome development and will certainly help the local real estate market.

Market Commentary 10/7/2022

Posted on by Damon Germanides

More Pain On The Horizon As Fed Pivot Is Deferred

The decent September jobs report had a “good news is bad news” effect on the markets. Traders were looking for signs that the Fed’s super-sized rate hikes are lowering wage inflation, which would indicate that overall inflation may be coming down. While wage growth eased and the overall jobs picture declined, it was not enough to sway the Fed from its restrictive stance. More likely than not, another .75 bp rate increase will occur at the next Fed meeting. Combining these large rate hikes with the balance sheet runoff, also known as QT, is quickly creating very cramped financial conditions. Our suspicion is that it will not take much longer for the Fed to break something in the financial system. Risks are high for a black swan type of event. There is real destruction happening in the marketplace as riskier bond yields start to tick up again. Oil is now over 90 and investor confidence is crumbling. It seems unlikely that the Fed can orchestrate an elegant economic soft landing. Caution remains the word du jour.

It is going to take time for real estate prices to adjust, especially in the way many of us believe they will.  It is simple math. If your cost of carry doubles this quickly, prices and cap rates must adjust despite a limited supply. Next week holds a lot of critical news for CPI, PPI, retail sales, and bank earnings. Buckle up as it is going to be a rough ride as we anticipate these updates. We hope things will not be as painful as the Fed wants us to believe.

Market Commentary 9/9/2022

Posted on by Damon Germanides

Equity Markets Move Higher, Encouraging Soft Landing For The Economy

U.S. equity markets proved resilient against the backdrop of a Hawkish Federal Reserve. Several voting members of the Fed spoke this week and the message was clear: short-term interest rates are going higher to combat inflation. The Fed wants input inflation to go down (think wages and energy) as well as consumption (think feeling poorer due to home value or retirement accounts being down).  However, the equity markets didn’t get the memo and rallied into the weekend.

Markets can sometimes react in a way that may seem irrational initially, but over time proves correct. In my mind, the equity rally suggests inflation may be coming down and job destruction may be happening more quickly. The so-called soft landing for the economy will be the result of Fed tightening. My prediction is there is more pain ahead. Volatile markets both up and down will be the norm for the balance of the year. The Fed will err on the side of higher interest rates for longer, which will put continued pressure on bonds and all investable assets. Remember, it takes time for the Fed’s policies to work their way into the system. That is why caution in this type of environment is so important.  Don’t fight the Fed. 

75 bp seems to be the likely direction in short-term interest rates when the Fed meets later this month.  That number was forecasted to the Wall Street Journal to help mitigate any surprises. The cost of debt is rising quickly. Higher yields are becoming attractive for savers, which is one positive to this so-called “return to normal interest rate” journey central bankers are taking us on. Real estate prices are adjusting as expected in the face of higher interest-carrying costs. Buyer and seller negotiating is back in vogue and all offers are being looked at. 

One interesting phenomenon that’s presented itself has me particularly excited to share. This past week Insignia Mortgage has located three new lending sources which specialize in the following: (1) financing high-net-worth domestic or foreign borrowers, (2) a new regional bank that offers attractive interest-only jumbo loans, and (3) a new commercial bank that offers investment property loans up to 20 million dollars. As rates have increased, so has the appetite to lend for those banks that didn’t chase yield to near zero. While business remains challenging, all is not lost in this wonderful free market economy we get to live in.

Market Commentary 8/19/2022

Posted on by Damon Germanides

Economy and Interest Rates Present Mixed Signals

Interest rates surged late in the week with the release of the alarming UK and Germany inflation data, especially within the context of a slowing economy. Mixed economic signals in the U.S. did not help markets either with slowing GDP or rising weekly unemployment claims. Nonetheless, there were some good manufacturing reports and a better-than-expected retail sales report. Existing housing sales softened again, resulting in home builders’ confidence being dismal. Housing starts also fell. Since housing is a major component of the economy, the current housing industry status is not positive.

The Fed and The Average American Head Towards Black Swan Event

The inability of the S&P to break through the 200-day moving average is challenging the bullish narrative.  Also, Fed speak, in my opinion, shows no signs of easing. Inflation is a problem, and it must be dealt with.  Talks of 75 bp rate hikes by Fed officials as well as the start of 95 billion balance sheet run-off per month are not accommodative. These discussions also raise the possibility of a black swan type of event.  However, not dealing with inflation now results in harsh problems for the average American. When food and life’s basic essentials become unaffordable to many, the government loses creditability.  This is what concerns Fed officials the most.

Real estate activity has slowed, but every market presents opportunities. Buyers are becoming increasingly more aggressive in negotiating with sellers. The combination of higher mortgage rates and tighter lending guidelines makes qualifying for a mortgage tougher. Thankfully, niche lenders are returning to fill in the gap. Adjustable-rate mortgages and interest-only products are in demand to offset the rise in mortgage rates.

Next week’s Jackson Hole symposium will be watched closely as central bankers, economists and the Fed chairman gather to speak about the economy and fiscal and monetary policy. Stay tuned for this. 

Market Commentary 7/22/2022

Posted on by Damon Germanides

Treasury Rates Decline As Corporate Earnings Disappoint

Inflation continues to deplete consumer spending power. This trend aligns with some very interesting reports from AT&T on the increase in late payments and rising defaults on smartphones. Since many of us can’t live without our smartphones for work or social interaction, failure to pay smartphone bills is concerning. It also suggests the economy may be worse off than many economists believed. Credit balances rise along with other loan types like non-performing auto loans and BNPL (buy now and pay later). The massive stimulus that was pumped into the market appears to have left the economy to work towards normalization while also battling high inflation and slowing growth. Many layoffs in the banking business are being announced. I expect unemployment to rise in the coming months as companies expand layoffs and banks pull back on lending. The recession is here, in my opinion. The big unknown is the Fed’s strategy to combat persistent inflation in a slowing economy. 

The Fed’s Big Squeeze

The haste with which the Fed has risen and may continue to raise short-term interest rates is squeezing all but the biggest banks. This squeeze is distressing for housing as banks pull back on LTVs, Cash-Out Refinances, and Investment Property Loans. Prices will need to adjust to the combination of higher interest rates and tighter bank guidelines. Mortgage banks that have filled the void on the more niche product offerings are also being affected. The one silver lining in all of this? There is a dramatic increase in housing inventory from very low levels of supply. There are many prospective buyers who have been waiting to buy for quite some time. Their time may be here in the upcoming months.

The ECB raised rates and now short-term interest rates are no longer zero. Personally, I never understand negative interest rates. As an observer, why would you lend money to get less of a return in the future?  As we witness this all in real-time, the winding down of easy money policies and as central banks experiment with negative interest rates, remember the old saying “it doesn’t make sense.”  Should inflation persist and the recession be deeper and longer than forecasted, central bankers in the developed world should remember the damage easy money policies have historically resulted in. While we all loved zero rates (or near zero or negative in some countries), the use of these policies is so destructive that it would be wiser to shelve them for future generations. Basic finance requires a discount rate to calculate risk properly. Ultra-low interest rates increase wealth and risk-taking, while rates remain low. The flip side is what happens when rates rise and inflation becomes unanchored, as we are experiencing today. Wealth is destroyed, confidence is eroded, and the most fragile in our society suffer through the high prices of basic necessities. Free money and zero interest rates have consequences. 

Market Commentary 07/01/2022

Posted on by Damon Germanides

Mortgage Rates Fall As Recession Fears Intensify

Treasury yields quickly raced to well under 3.00% this week. In my opinion, this is not a good sign of things to come. Recession fears have escalated. The long bond acts like this when recession fears rise.  GDP now has economic growth at -2.1%. Micron, a major chip supplier, guided down and reaffirmed what many of us already know. The economy is slowing. The combination of Fed rate hikes and quantitative tightening is a dangerous cocktail for the equity, real estate, and debt markets. I am hearing from several banks that liquidity is quickly drying up. They are weary to lend, and risk spreads have increased. As expected, housing supply has jumped as homeowners look to sell before things get worse, or in some cases unload their second or third home. A violent stock market and bitcoin correction have consumer confidence at a many years low, with liquid savings and retirement accounts down a great deal.  With margins being squeezed and earnings estimates falling, S&P year-end estimates have come down with year-end S&P to be somewhere in the range of 3,200 and 4,100.   

Where Do We Go From Here? Equity, Real Estate, Inflation. 

First, let us start with the equity market. Equities rise and fall and are prone to large drawdowns and rebounds. Many of us got into trouble chasing momentum stocks and high beta tech stocks, which have no earnings power.  Stocks represent ownership in a business, but zero rates and money spraying had fooled many professionals into believing that stocks only go up. The same applies to crypto. 

Two, regarding real estate, price is what you pay, and value is what you get.  Homes are a bit different asset class than other real estate as many homeowners were able to lock in exceptionally low-interest rates. Even if the housing market declines, homeowners will be able to service their debts. Home appreciation over the last few years has been unsustainable. The new listings appearing amidst the dwindling economy warrant the need for a correction. People are becoming increasingly cautious. As interest rates return to the historical mean, speculation will lighten, and buyers and sellers can enter a more even playing field.   

Three, the Fed will beat inflation. It is already happening. It will occur at a significant cost and over time, but inflation will come down. The Fed’s tools are very good at breaking inflation (higher rates and quantitative tightening). The collective negative sentiment compounded with quickly deteriorating financial conditions indicates the need for the Fed to halt its rate-hiking cycle expeditiously. The 2-year Treasury has fallen mightily the last few days which supports the notion of fewer rate hikes ahead.

Finally, it is important to remember that this is a long game. Absent the last 20 years or so, recessions and rebounds were much more common.  Recessions clean out the financial system and are healthy.  Speculators are taught about assessing risk, bad companies die off – clearing the way for new more innovative businesses, and prices reset allowing investors to buy assets for cheaper.  While I may be negative on the markets currently, I am always bullish on America. We have so much to be grateful for, even in tough times.

Have a great 4th of July.

Market Commentary 06/24/2022

Posted on by Damon Germanides

Treasury Yields Dip On Fears Of Slowing Economy

The economy is slowing. This is evidenced by the recent layoffs amidst many technology companies, lenders, and other businesses that were benefactors of stay-at-home and low-interest rates. The leisure industry remains strong as people continue to spend money on experiences and travel, with the exception of restaurants, which seem a lot less busy. Many clients are complaining about the cost of living which becomes exacerbated in a downward trending equity market. The front-page news of a looming recession and its potential certainly does not help quell public concern. Consumer and business confidence remains low. In my opinion, there is a fairly good chance the economy is already in a recession. It certainly feels that way. 

Inflation Is Always And Everywhere A Monetary Phenomenon

If the Fed has the resolve to break inflation, it will. More clarity should be available by the end of next week when the PCE inflation reading (the Fed’s favorite gauge of inflation) is released. Should that reading come in hot or as expected, the Fed will most likely go up 75 bp again in July. The old saying that “inflation is always and everywhere a monetary phenomenon” rings true these days. The markets will stay volatile during the next few months as the new terminal rate for rate hiking is established. There’s a big chance that the Fed’s double-barreled strategy of increases in rates and balance sheet runoffs could result in them breaking something in the financial system. Caution remains warranted even during strong rallies like today.

I expect the Fed to move above 3% on Fed funds sooner than later. 40% of Americans are now living paycheck-to-paycheck and are struggling to pay for life necessities. The one positive here is that I think the Fed is now taking inflation seriously enough to ensure that it should come down fairly quickly, maybe by the fall. That is just my best guess. Earlier this week, the yield curve continues to be flat and briefly inverted. This is almost always an ominous sign.

Interest Rates In The Ether

How higher interest rates will affect home prices is yet to be established. My belief is that prices will need to come down. Some models are showing a 20% or so draw down in values. However, in supply-constrained cities like Los Angeles, there are still not enough homes to meet demand. Should interest rates remain persistently high, I imagine home prices will slide even in supply-constrained markets. I am hearing from commercial bankers that higher interest rates will have an immediate effect on cap rates and that exit cap rates have been reduced as well. Cautious underwriting is being implemented across the board, which I applaud. Better to stress-test loan applicants than be sloppy in a rising rate environment. I expect as interest rates remain elevated, refinance of real estate will be used to pay down more expensive personal or business debt.  ARM loans and interest-only loan demand has picked up. Borrowers are attempting to offset the rise in interest rates with an interest-only payment. 

Market Commentary 5/20/2022

Posted on by Damon Germanides

Equity Market Volatility Pushes Bond Yields Lower

It was another week of agonizing volatility in both the bond and equity markets. Big box retailers reported tighter margins due to high inflation. Economists continue to move year-end targets down. One wonders if all of this negativity signifies an end to selling.  S&P touched correction territory before trading higher into the close on Friday.  Long-dated bond yields fell below 2.800%. Trading remains volatile but orderly.  As we have mentioned previously, don’t expect the Fed to step in and backstop the equity or housing market anytime soon.  Inflation is the Fed’s primary concern and they will tolerate a falling equity market and a higher unemployment rate to subdue inflation. Case in point, the WSJ reported that subprime credit delinquencies are rising from historically low levels as the increased cost of food and energy preys on consumers.  Even the wealthy appear to be cutting back on spending. The soaring costs across all corners of the economy are weighing on people’s confidence and willingness to spend.

Impact On Real Estate & The Global Economy 

Limited housing inventory will keep home prices from falling too dramatically. However, given the wealth destruction incurred in both the bond and equity market, it is difficult to see real estate being impervious to recent events. The dramatic rise in mortgage rates over the last 60 days will push some buyers to the sidelines. 

With China shut down, and the world economy slowing, perhaps long-term interest rates will continue their recent descent. This would be helpful to growth stocks in addition to homebuyers, consumers, and businesses. We hope that long rates don’t move too low, as an inverted yield curve would be worrisome. Housing demand remains healthy, which bodes well overall for the economy.  Should this change, we would become very nervous over a deep recession. 

Next week is important for the markets as the Fed’s favorite inflation gauge, the PCE, is released.  The markets will respond favorably should inflation appear to be topping out.  However, should the reading come in hotter than expected, be prepared for a sobering market reaction.